Science and Behavior: Evaluation Techniques

S.B. – 20
11/3/2017
Evaluation Techniques Based on Measurement
In an experiment one measures observable variables in a controlled environment, and that measurement becomes a numerical description. Measurement can be defined as a process of assigning symbols to varying magnitudes of these given properties according to a set of rules. Developing exact devices of measurement is a requirement of all of the sciences.
20-1. The measurement process is a tool which is used to observe the amount of something.
A. True
B. False(A)
20-2. In psychology as well as in physics and chemistry, it is necessary to develop exact devices of measurement.
A. True
B. FalseAnswer. (A)

20-3. Measurement is numerical description.
A. True
B. False

Answer. (A)

20-4 There is no particular rule or criterion for assigning symbols.
A. True
B. False

Answer. (B)

Let us now consider some of the simple measures of responses commonly used in psychology (the memory device is A RED FLAP):

A. Accuracy measured in terms of distance from a given point (e.g. Bulls Eye in target practice)

R. Rate: the amount of something per unit of time (e.g. a child does 5 addition problems in 4 minutes)

E. Errors (e.g. the more proficient you are at a task, the fewer errors you make)

D. Duration of a response: the time between the beginning of a response and its termination (e.g. a person’s proficiency at parking a car could be measured by the time required to perform such a task)

F. Frequency of response (e.g. the more frequent the bar is pressed, the better the learning)

L. Latency of a response: the time between the onset of the stimulus and the subject’s initiation of the response (e.g. reaction time)

A. Amplitude: amount of or force of the response (e.g. amount of salivation)

P. Percentage of correct responses or the percentage of time that the appropriate response occurs. Many behaviors are such that this measurement is easily used, e.g. percentage of time a child is out of his classroom seat, percentage of time thumb sucking, or percentage of time a student’s head is on the desk.

One can add to this list:
One: Saving score – How many trials does one save in relearning a task by recall, reconstruction, reproduction, or recognition?

Two: Percentage and Rate Compared – In many cases only one response may follow a stimulus, but in others many responses occur.

Three: Rating scales (e.g. rating the quality of a given response)

Four: Trials to criterion (e.g. how many trials it takes to produce a perfect performance).

Five: Trials to extinction or termination of behavior after stopping the procedure (e.g. how many trials it takes to get rid of a behavior).

20-5. Measurements of behavior might include
A. frequency of response
B. rate of response
C. trials to criterion
D. techniques
E. saving score

Answer. (A, B, C, E)

20-6. Measurement of behavior might include
A. response latency
B. response duration
C. amount of response
D. amplitude of response
E. errors

Answer. (A, B, C, D, E)

20-7. In measuring performance, we define the time from the onset of the stimulus to the onset of the response as the
A. interval period
B. initial period
C. Latency
D. time out

Answer. (C)

20-8. The time between the stimulus and response is
A. Latency
B. magnitude
C. reflex arc
D. response

Answer. (A)

20-9 During learning, the amplitude of a response should
A. decrease
B. increase
C. first decrease and then increase
D. first increase and then decrease

Answer. (B)

20-10. Reaction time provides us with an example of psychological research on latency being applied to everyday affairs. In which of the following is reaction time being measured?
A. a doctor testing for the mere presence of the knee jerk reflex
B. a motor vehicle official measuring how long an applicant takes to push a brake pedal after a light flashes
C. an Army officer measuring the rate at which a recruit can run a two mile course.
D. all of the above

Answer. (B)

20-11. Which of the following is not a response measure listed in the text?
A. rate
B. latency
C. amplitude
D. money spent

Answer. (D)

RATE AND CUMULATIVE RECORD

One of the response measures presented in the previous unit will be discussed in detail. Stages exist when rate is used as a response measure. Advantages of rate as a means of learning will be elaborated on later.

20-12. Figure 1: A broad strip of paper is unwinding from a roll. The end of the strip is moving slowly and steadily toward the left. A pen held against the paper in a fixed position, has drawn a line beginning at _______ and ending at __________.

Answer. (A, B)

20-13. Figure 2: The slow movement of the paper under the fixed pen has drawn the horizontal line from ________ to _____. At “b” the pen suddenly moved a short distance upward to ____________.

Answer. (A, B, C)

20-14. Figure 3: the paper has moved a short distance beyond the position shown in Figure 2. The fixed pen has drawn a second horizontal line from _____ to _______.

Answer. (C, D)

20-15. Figure 3: the pen has been in the four positions, a, b, c, d. It occupied position _________ first and ________ last.

Answer. (A, D)

20-16. Figure 3: The time which elapsed between C and D was _____________ than the time which elapsed between A and B.

Answer. (SHORTER)
20-17. In recording the responses made by an organism the pen moves upward and draws a short vertical line each time a response is made. In Figure 4, an experiment began when the pen was at a. The first response was made at _________________.

Answer. (B)

20-18. Figure 4: three responses were made fairly quickly, and at a steady rate at, ____ , ____ ,and _____.

Answer. (C, D, E)

20-19. Figure 5: the three responses recorded at “A” were emitted _________ rapidly than the three at “B.”

Answer. (LESS)

20-20. The more rapid the responding, the ________ the pause between responses.

Answer. (SHORTER)

20-21. The higher the rate of responding, the ___________ the horizontal line drawn by the pen between successive responses.

Answer. (SHORTER)

20-22. Figure 5: the more rapid the responding, the ________ the slope of the step like line.

Answer. (HIGHER)

20-23. Rate of responding is shown by the ____________ of the step-like line.

Answer. (SLOPE)

20-24. Figure 6: Responding begins at a relatively high rate at “A.” The time between successive responses becomes progressively _____________.

Answer. (SLOWER)

20-25. Figure 6: the slope of the first part of the curve drawn by the pen beginning at “A” is relatively _________.

Answer. (STEEP)

20-26. Figure 7: the rate increases fairly steadily from a low value near _________ to a high value near _______.

Answer. (A, B)

20-27. An increase in rate is called positive acceleration. Positive acceleration is shown in Figure ______.

Answer. (6 or 7)

20-28. Negative acceleration refers to a(n)________ in rate.

Answer. (DECREASE)

20-29. Negative acceleration is shown in Figure ___________.

Answer. (6 or 7)

20-30. To record other events which occur while an animal is responding, the pen swings quickly “to the southeast” and back again. In Figure 8 the pen has just drawn a line from _______ to ________. The point of the pen will immediately return to is ___________.

Answer. (D, E, D)

20-31. Figure 8: The short mark (“hatch” or “pip’) at _______ was made by the same movement of the pen as shown at “D-E.”

Answer. (C)

20-32. The “southeast” mark or hatch is often used to indicate that a response has been reinforced (rewarded). In Figure 8, reinforced responses were recorded by the vertical marks at ______ and ________.

Answer. (C, D)

20-33. Figure 10: a response was reinforced at _____.

Answer. (D)

20-34. In practice, the vertical mark made by a single response is too small to be easily identified. However, we can still use the _____ of the curve at any point as a valid indicator of rate of responding.

Answer. (SLOPE)

20-35. Figure 10: the rate was highest between ________ and ________, zero between ________ and _______, and of an intermediate value between ________ and _____________.

Answer. (A-B; B-C; C-D)

20-36. When the steps are so small that we cannot count responses, we can still determine the number of responses between two points on the record by using a scale. In figure 9, the scale at the right tells us that responses occur approximately _______ minutes apart.

Answer. (5)

20-37. If the paper moves very slowly, we may not be able to measure accurately the time between two responses, but we can still determine the time elapsing between two chosen points. In figure 9 the scale at the right tells us that responses at A and B in the cumulative record at the left occurred approximately _____ minutes apart.

Answer. (5)

20-38. Figure 10: after completing about 5 responses between a and b, the animal paused for a short period, _____ to _____, and then emitted about ______ responses between C and D.

Answer. (B, C, 5)

20-39. When a cumulative curve is used to record animal behavior the slope indicates _________.

Answer. (RATE)

20-40. “Rate of responding” means number of responses per unit time. In a cumulative record, number of responses can be determined from the distance traversed by the pen in a ____________ direction.

Answer. (VERTICAL)

20-41. In a cumulative record, time is indicated by the distance traversed by the pen in a __________ direction.

Answer. (HORIZONTAL)

1 Skinner, B.F., Cumulative Record 1959, p. 178-182, Appleton-Century Crofts