Grammar Girl’s Editing Checklist

Grammar Girl’s Editing Checklist

If you don’t know Grammar Girl, you should.  She has pithy and helpful blog posts of all matters grammar.
The excerpt below is from a Grammar Girl blog post.
Follow the link at the bottom to see her printable Editing Checklist.  It’s very helpful!

“…we distributed a Grammar Girl editing checklist that turned out to be so popular we decided to make it widely available. Print out the checklist and keep it on your desk as a handy reference to use when you’re editing.

By

Mignon Fogarty,

May 8, 2014

 

Assertive Language

In the business world, one wants to appear assertive and confident. Using “hedging” or conditional words undermines the reader’s confidence in the writer.

The most common words that undermine a writer are: seems, appears, maybe. To make your writing more assertive, delete these conditional words. Some examples appear below.

  • Not assertive: It appears that the engineering department receives much of the blame.
  • Assertive: The engineering department receives much of the blame.
  • Not assertive: It seemed like everyone thought there was a different problem.
  • Assertive: Everyone thought there was a different problem.
  • Not assertive: The XYZ Corporation appears to be very successful.
  • Assertive: The XYZ Corporation is very successful.
  • Not assertive: The R&D team is pretty much off the hook.
  • Assertive: The R&D team is off the hook. (This is terrible vocabulary, however.)
  • Not assertive: The first recommendation I would make is to spell check your document.
  • Assertive: First, I recommend you spell check your document.
  • Not assertive: I think that maybe what the company should do is hire a consultant.
  • Assertive: The company should hire a consultant.

Now that you have seen some examples, look for conditional words in your writing and eliminate as many as possible.

Take the Bull by the Horns White BackgroundCreative Commons License One Way Stock via Compfight

Unclear Referents–or Why Does My Paper say “ref”?

 Why Does my Paper Say “Ref”?

Tennessee Journalist via CompfightTennessee Journalist via Compfight

To ensure your writing is clear and easy to read, pronouns must clearly refer to a noun in the current or previous sentence.  The reader must know what noun the pronoun is replacing. The “ref” designation on an edited piece of writing means the referent is unclear.

 

A pronoun refers to a noun (he/she, they, them, it etc.)

An antecedent (or referent) is the noun to which the pronoun refers.

Identify the pronoun and antecedent in this sentence:

  • Many students are anxious when they have to take an exam.

The pronoun is “they.”  “The antecedent is “students.”  This sentence is clear.

 

 

In this sentence, the reference is unclear:

  • Both John and Will loved his new IPod.

The pronoun is “his” but the reader does not know if the “his” is John or Bill.  This sentence is unclear because the reader cannot tell who loves the IPod.

Another example shows confusion in sentences in which two or more nouns are possible antecedents. The following sentence is unclear:

 

  • When the president objected to Mr. Carter, he told him to mind his own business.

(Who told whom?)

 

This revision is clear:

  • When the president objected to Mr. Carter, Mr. Carter told him to mind his own business.

 

Confusion also occurs when the pronoun does not have an antecedent or the antecedent is implied. This sentence is unclear:

 

  • Students should not allow the mixture to boil; so when they do it, watch the temperature gauge.

 

The “it” in the second clause does not have an antecedent, which makes the sentence confusing. The following revision is correct:

  • Students should not allow the mixture to boil; so when conducting the experiment, watch the temperature gauge.

 

 

 

The rules to ensure clear pronoun referents are:

  • Do not use “they” when referring to unspecified persons (generalizing); “they” must refer to specific people.
  • Terms such as everyone, everybody, anybody, company, committee are singular and take singular pronouns.
  • Use “it” and “that” when referring to a specific word or phrase.
  • Pronouns must agree in number with their antecedents
    • Plural antecedents need plural pronouns
      • Incorrect:   Each person should follow their major plan.
      • Correct:     Students should follow their major plan.
      • Incorrect:   Everybody should plan for their retirement.
      • Correct:     Everybody should plan for his or her retirement.

Sentence Structure

 

Are your sentences clear and easy to read or messy and confusing?

tanakawho via Compfight

Creating clear sentences is essential for all writers.  Some common sentence structure problems are explained below.

 

Agreement means the subject (noun, doer of action) and verbs (the action) must agree in number and tense:

  •      “A company is” is correct; “a company are” is incorrect.
  •      “I wrote” is correct; “I written” is incorrect.

Sentences must end with a period or other punctuation.

Fused sentences are complete sentences run together without punctuation; to fix, separate sentences with a period, a conjunction (and, but etc.), or a semicolon.

  • Correct: I didn’t know which job I wanted.  I was too confused to decide.
  • Incorrect:  I didn’t know which job I wanted I was too confused to decide.·

Comma splices are two sentences (independent clauses)  joined by a comma; to fix, replace the comma with a period, a conjunction (and, but etc.), or a semicolon.

  • Correct: I woke up late this morning.  I didn’t have time for breakfast.
  • Incorrect: I woke up late this morning, I didn’t have time for breakfast.

Sentence fragments are phrases that lack a subject or verb.

  •  Correct: The five days spent in the library were boring.
  •  Incorrect: The five days spent in the library.

Edit your writing carefully to avoid these sentence structure errors.

Parallel Construction

 

 

 

All items in a list need to be in the same format; this is called parallel construction.

Parallelism occurs in several ways. First, within a single sentence, a list should start with the same verb form. For example, the following sentence is not parallel: I am good at working in teams, being able to communicate, lack fear, having a positive attitude. The verbs are: working, being, lack, having. To be parallel, the verbs need to be: working, communicating, lacking, having. Here’s another example:

Not parallel:

Some personal values that are important to me in my career are:

  1. Making a lot of money to support my family
  2. Being able to enjoy my field of work
  3. Managing a new business
  4. Making a new business succeed
  5. Become recognized as a major business in the country

Here the verbs are: making, being, managing, and become. To be parallel, the verbs need to be: making, being, managing, and becoming.

Parallel:

Some personal values that are important to me in my career are:

  1. Making a lot of money to support my family
  2. Being able to enjoy my field of work
  3. Managing a new business
  4. Making a new business succeed
  5. Becoming recognized as a major business in the country

 

Not parallel:

  • Participated in meetings
  • Strengthened interpersonal skills

o   Word, Excel, PowerPoint

Parallel:

  • Participated in meetings
  • Strengthened interpersonal skills

o   Developed skills in Word, Excel, PowerPoint

In the next pair, the structure of the listed items requires parallel construction. All items need to be either phrases or complete sentences, not some of each.

Not Parallel:

Values that I feel are important for me to have in my work and career are:

  1. Team working skills
  2. Being able to communicate with others
  3. Not being afraid to say my ideas
  4. I should not judge people.
  5. Have a positive attitude

 

In this list, item number four is a complete sentence while the others are not. The following is parallel.

Parallel:

Values that I feel are important for me to have in my work and career are:

  1. Team working skills
  2. Being able to communicate with others
  3. Not being afraid to say my ideas
  4. Not judging people.
  5. Have a positive attitude

The Lonely This

Self-Fulfilling Prophecy Robert Hruzek via Compfight

Writers often use “This” to refer to the subject of the previous sentence. However, using the pronoun “this” alone is sometimes called a Lonely This. A subject should follow a “This.”

A Lonely This looks like:

  • This is mine.
  • This is likely due to too much freedom.
  •  This left them feeling inadequate.

In each of these examples, the reader does not know to what the “This” refers. The “This” is lonely because it doesn’t have a subject.

Writers should identify the “This” as in the following examples:

  • This textbook is mine.
  •  This problem is likely due to too much freedom.
  •  This problem left them feeling inadequate.

In these examples, the “This” is followed by a noun. The more specificity in your writing, the easier it is to read because the reader doesn’t have to re-read sections to determine your subject.

 

Active and Passive Verbs

Active and Passive voice causes  writers many, many problems. In business writing, you want to use active voice because sentences in active voice are more direct and forceful. Active voice sentences clearly identify who is doing the action. This reduces confusion and increases brevity in business documents.

In passive voice, who or what does the action of the sentence is implied, unknown, or comes after the verb in the sentence. Passive voice is often used when a writer wants to deflect blame or criticism, or when the action of the sentence is more important than the doer/actor.

The easiest way to determine if a verb is active or passive is to ask the following two questions:

What is the verb?

Who/what is doing the action (verb)?

If you know who is acting = active voice

If you’re unsure who is acting = passive voice

 

Are the following sentences active or passive?

1.     Companies expect accounting positions to increase in the next ten years.

  • What is the verb? Expect
  • Who/what is expecting? Companies
  • This sentence is active.

2.  They have to work with computers.

  • What is the verb? Work
  • Who is working? “They”
  • This sentence is active.

3.   The report was left on the desk.

  • What is the verb? Left
  • Who/what left the report? We don’t know.
  • This sentence is passive.

4.  Several students were failed because of poor writing.

  • What is the verb? Failed
  • Who failed the students? We don’t know.
  • This sentence is passive.

 

Once you’ve identified passive verbs, how do you change them to active verbs?

 

  1. Identify the verb
  2. Identify who is doing the action of the verb.
  3. Name the actor as the subject.

 

Consider the following examples of passive verbs changed into active verbs.

  • I was identified by the MBTI as an IFNJ.
  1. Verb is “identified”
  2. Who identified? The MBTI
  3. Revised: The MBTI identified me as an IFNJ.

 

  • A new program was devised for making automatic payments.
  1. Verb is “devised”
  2. Who devised? We don’t know, so we must add or name the subject
  3. Revised: Technicians devised a new program for making automatic payments. Or: The new program is for making automatic payments.

Now, find the passive verbs in your writing by asking:

  1. What is the verb?
  2. Who is doing the action of the verb?

Change the sentence to active voice by naming the actor (who/what does the action of the verb) first in the sentence (before the verb).