In our Spring 2020 HiEd820: The College Student course, doctoral students had the opportunity to choose between writing a book review and participating in a course discussion. This assignment, created by Dr. Brittany Williams, was developed to help students explore academic writing forms beyond the traditional paper format and to give students an opportunity to interweave a book review with other assigned course readings. The following review was created by first-year doctoral student Kimberley Turner-Rush. Given the distance between the books’ publication and the changing realities of higher education in the current political landscape, this text remains relevant to all who seek to serve and support students on campus. If you’re looking for a quarantine read that can shed light on educational precarity and access issues, this book should be on your list.

— Brittany M. Williams, Ph.D.

LOWER ED: The Troubling Rise of For-Profit Colleges in the New Economy (Review)

Cottom, T.M. (2017). Lower Ed. The Troubling Rise of For-Profit Colleges in the New Economy. New York, NY. The New Press.

Many have viewed education as a way to change the trajectory of an entire family for generations to come (Song, 2016). Cottom’s (2017) book, Lower Ed: The Troubling Rise of For-Profit Colleges in the New Economy, provides readers insight on how students’ socioeconomic status plays a role in higher education. Cottom not only addresses attainment, but also the types of educational opportunities that are available to students as well as how the systems in place can both discourage their participation and take advantage of their desire for participation.

Championed as the great equalizer, higher education has been dangled like a carrot to lower- and lower-middle-class people as a way to climb the socioeconomic ladder to a better life.

Photo by Dr. Tressie McMillan Cottom via Wikimedia Commons

Currently an Associate Professor in the Department of Sociology at Virginia Commonwealth University, Cottom hails from a professional background of working at both for-profit and not-for-profit institutions of higher education. Her experience provides insight into practices of enrolling students in programs that, more often than not, do not meet the expectations outlined and can often leave students in financial distress. Cottom’s disdain for these practices is evident as she proclaims, “the idea that higher education is a moral good is allowable only insofar as higher education serves market interests.” 

When we remove the notion that, for many, obtaining higher education is more about job attainment and less about the social good, we are forced to look in the mirror and ask whether or not the work of higher education institutions as we currently conceive it functions for all students who are enrolling with the hope of a brighter future. Cottom provides the reader with insight or themes impacting how we, as practitioners, interact with students as well as how we should be working with populations of students who need our services most.

When reading Lower Ed, themes that practitioners should consider emerge regarding processes for recruiting and enrolling students, labor market drivers for programming, and organizational structures to support students determined to complete a college education. These takeaways should continue to be at the forefront of discussions of higher education practitioners and shape how we serve our students. It is our responsibility to rethink both our purpose(s) as higher education practitioners and our understanding of what students want (and need) from our institutions.

Recruitment and Enrollment Practices

Cottom remarkably illustrates how the “flexible solutions” offered by the for-profit schools continue to exacerbate social inequities and foster discrimination.

Students enrolling in these programs are less likely to have attended good K-12 schools that offer college prep courses. They are more likely to face food and housing insecurities (AAC&U News, 2019) and less likely to have access to standardized test prep. By seeking education at a for-profit institution, they are more likely to take on higher debt to cover the higher costs.

The not-for-profit sector must find ways to allow flexible enrollment schedules, online courses, and online program completion as just a few of the benefits students can expect. Additionally, many for-profit institutions do not require developmental courses, so students start immediately on their chosen academic path. In addition to finding ways to better accommodate the for-profit demographic, we must do so in a way that reduces equity gaps as these students are more likely to fall into a group that Anthony Jack refers to as the doubly disadvantaged (2015).  Cottom indicates that students often feel pressured into signing enrollment agreements and that they do not fully understand the burden of this debt. 

Doubly Disadvantaged

Jack’s (2015) work compares the experience of students of color who enter college from local, public high schools (doubly disadvantaged) and those students of color who graduate from preparatory or boarding schools (privileged poor). These distinctions are essential in understanding the needs of the students we serve. The doubly disadvantaged have had little access to the resources that make college transition smooth and college completion attainable. These students are unaware that professors expect students to reach out if they need help and expect students to seek assistance when obstacles arise. Using the close relationships with our K-12 partners, not-for-profit institutions of higher education are positioned to have discussions on how to close these gaps. If we fail to do so, we are complacent and are further enabling a system that, as Cottom indicates, continues to exacerbate social inequities and fosters discrimination.

Labor Market Drivers

Students enrolled in for-profit institutions tend to be women, people of color, and single parents who are of lower socioeconomic status than their traditional college peers (Cottom, 2017). For many of these individuals, a college education provides preparation for a job, knowledge needed for a better job, or credentials required to pursue a coveted position and be competitive in the job market.

istockphoto.com

While access barriers are a large driver to for-profit undergraduate programs, why do for-profit graduate degrees continue to flourish? Cottom offers one example that focuses on a group of black women enrolled in online PhD programs offered mainly through the University of Phoenix, Capella University, and Walden University. These women, known as Sisters Working to Achieve Greatness (SWAG), are obtaining what Cottom refers to as up-market degrees at a much higher cost without the off-setting opportunities such as teaching assistantships or institutional aid. Up-market degrees are “credential sequences that start at the lower level, with higher degrees stacked on top as demand increases” (Cottom, 2017). The women of SWAG are spending $92,000 to $180,000 for degrees (up to and including the doctorate) through student loans. While these women see the cost as a good investment, others Cottom follows view education as a means to add letters behind their name for the perceived prestige those letters provide.

 

Organizational Structure and Student Support

One way that community colleges strive to support students is through innovation and wrap-around services such as childcare resources, tutoring, transportation, etc. (Dembicki, 2019).

Cottom counters with the fact that the understaffing of community colleges in service areas, overcrowding, and demands of remedial or developmental courses put strains on these institutions and leave students to overcome these obstacles on their own. Obstacles that students are less likely to face in the for-profit sector.

It is evident that the current not-for-profit systems are not meeting students’ needs in overcoming these obstacles. Much of this relates to the difference in funding structures between not-for-profit and for-profit institutions. To improve these systems and be better positioned to meet the needs of students, community colleges (and four-year institutions) will need a better funding model that offers incentives for the necessary changes to be made. Until then, Cottom offers focus areas (themes) that practitioners can use when developing or updating services and programs that serve the students most in need of our support. Perhaps we should all heed her advice.

References

AAC&U News. (2019). Majority of College Students Experience Food Insecurity, Housing Insecurity, or Homelessness.

Cottom, T. M. (2017). Lower Ed; The Troubling Rise of For-Profit Colleges in the New Economy. The New Press.

Dembricki, M. (2019). Wraparound services and student success. Community College Daily. Retrieved http://www.ccdaily.com/2019/05/wraparound-services-student-success/.

Jack, A. (2015).  “What the Privileged Poor Can Teach Us.” The New York Times.

Jack, A. (2019, June 13). On Diversity: Access Ain’t Inclusion. TEDxCambridge. https://youtu.be/j7w2Gv7ueOc.

Jack, A. (2019, March 6). The Privileged Poor. YouTube. https://youtu.be/ZXKKmPCZPDc

Song, X. (2016). Diverging Mobility Trajectories: Grandparent Effects on Educational Attainment in One- and Two-Parent Families. Demography. 53(6). 1905-1932.

U.S. Department of Education. College Affordability and Completion: Ensuring a Pathway to Opportunity. https://www.ed.gov/college.

 

About the Author:

Kim Turner-Rush is an instructor of business at Saint Paul College. She lives in downtown Saint Paul, a transplant from Cincinnati, OH. She holds a M.A. in Higher Education Administration and an MBA from Morehead State University. Currently, Kim is enrolled in the Higher Education Administration doctoral program at Saint Cloud State University.

3,854 thoughts on “What is “Lower Ed” and Are We Continuing to Push it On Students?

  1. Collective conversations in OMT classes develop exhilaration аround mathematics concepts,
    inspiring Singapore trainees tօ establish love аnd stand ᧐ut
    in examinations.

    Join ᧐ur smаll-ɡroup on-site classes іn Singapore fⲟr tailored assistance
    in a nurturing environment thаt builds strong foundational mathematics abilities.

    Αs mathematics underpins Singapore’ѕ reputation fօr quality in worldwide criteria ⅼike PISA,
    math tuition іs crucial tο unlocking a child’s possіble and protecting academic benefits іn this
    core subject.

    Math tuition addresses specific discovering paces, allowing primary school students
    tօ deepen understanding of PSLE topics lіke аrea, boundary, and volume.

    With Ⲟ Levels stressing geometry proofs ɑnd theories, math tuition ρrovides specialized drills tߋ ensure pupils ⅽan deal with these
    witһ accuracy and self-confidence.

    Junior college math tuition cultivates іmportant assuming abilities neеded to solve non-routine proƅlems that commonly appеar in A Level mathematics analyses.

    Inevitably, OMT’ѕ distinct proprietary syllabus enhances
    tһe Singapore MOE curriculum ƅу cultivating independent thinkers furnished fߋr long-lasting mathematical success.

    OMT’ѕ online ѕystem enhances MOE syllabus оne, assisting уou tackle PSLE math witһ simplicity ɑnd
    mᥙch better ratings.

    Tuition programs track progression carefully, motivating Singapore trainees ѡith visible
    improvements reѕulting in test goals.

    Τake а ⅼook at my web blog … Math Classes

  2. VN88 liên tục tung ra các chương trình khuyến mãi khủng để tri ân cược thủ. Link vào VN88 là đường dẫn chính thức, giúp bạn nhận ưu đãi một cách nhanh nhất. Gia nhập ngay VN88 NG để chinh phục các game cá cược như Rồng Hổ, Sicbo và khám phá thế giới thể thao ảo đầy kịch tính.

  3. با احترام فراوان
    توصیه دارم ببینید
    سایت انفجار بت
    رو برای انفجار 2.
    این اپ کاربردی پرداخت مطمئن
    و برای علاقه‌مندان ورزش مناسبه.

    بهترین سایت شرط بندیو به نظرم ارزش داره.

    کاربر قدیمی.

    Reviеw my website … شرط سه تایی در اکسل:
    راهنمای جامع برای کاربران سایت شرط بندی و
    علاقهمندان به تحلیل دادهها
    (Sharron)

  4. Hey there! Do you know if they make any plugins to help with Search Engine Optimization? I’m trying to get my blog to rank for some targeted keywords but
    I’m not seeing very good gains. If you know of any please
    share. Cheers!

    Also visit my web site … S-Rank Attack agent guide

  5. Great blog here! Also your web site rather a lot up fast!
    What host are you using? Can I am getting your associate
    hyperlink on your host? I wish my website loaded up as quickly as yours lol

    Look at my homepage: Kathrin

  6. What’s Happening i’m new to this, I stumbled upon this
    I’ve found It positively helpful and it has aided me out loads.
    I am hoping to give a contribution & assist other users like its helped me.

    Good job.

    My webpage; phim sex doggy

  7. Howdy! Someone in my Myspace group shared
    this website with us so I came to look it over. I’m definitely enjoying the
    information. I’m bookmarking and will be tweeting this to my followers!
    Wonderful blog and amazing style and design.

    Review my web-site – gilabet888

  8. ทางเข้า ufabet,m dafabet,ufabet เว็บตรงทางเข้า,ufa888 ทางเข้า ufabet มือถือ,ทางเข้า ufabet มือถือ,w88 ทางเข้า มือถือ,fun88 มือถือ https://fun88gambling.com

  9. درود و احترام محمد
    توصیه دارم تست کنید
    سایت بوکس پیش بینی
    رو برای تخته نرد شرطی.
    این سرویس اپ حرفه ای و برای بلک جک عالیه.

    امنیتش عالیه و توصیه دارم
    امتحان کنید.
    با آرزوی موفقیت.

    Fеel free to suгf to my webpage: لینک دانشگاهی شهرکرد
    قوی (Dannielle)

  10. روز بخیر
    توصیه دارم تست کنید
    سایت رولت آنلاین
    رو برای شرط بندی.
    این وبسایت خوب بونوس ثبت نام و برای بازیکنان کازینو خوبه.

    به نظرم بهترینه و توصیه می‌کنم چک کنید.

    سپاس علی.

    My site خبرگزاری وبلاگ دانشجویان

  11. 上海过桥垫资公司单边贷款,上海抵押贷款过桥垫资,上海大额过桥垫资全款买房,上海垫资过桥买房靠谱吗,上海企业过桥垫资复批吗,上海过桥垫资大额信用贷款风控术 https://www.mymse88.com

  12. درود فراوان علی
    پیشنهاد می‌دم ببینید
    سایت فرمول یک پیش بینی
    رو در حوزه پاسور.
    این سرویس معتبر اپلیکیشن موبایل داره و برای حرفه‌ای‌ها مناسبه.

    کیفیت بالایی داره و پیشنهاد می‌کنم شما هم امتحان کنید.

    پایدار باشید.

    Alѕo visit my page چگونه بازی تخته نرد کامپیوتر تحولی در دنیای شرط بندی و سرگرمیهای ایرانی ایجاد کرده است؟

  13. عرض ادب محمد آقا
    حتما سر بزنید
    سایت کازینو حرفه ای
    رو برای تخته نرد.
    این سرویس سریع تنوع بالا و برای پاسور بازها جذابه.

    تازه کشف کردم و حتما ببینیدش.

    ارادتمند شما.

    Alѕoo vіsit my ƅloց post: سایت خبری بورسیه رویدادها – http://polyinform.com.ua/user/DominikStaten6,

  14. عرض ادب
    حتما امتحان کنید اپ
    سایت کازینو حرفه ای
    رو برای بازی‌های ورزشی.

    این وبسایت پرداخت آنی وبرای
    کازینو زنده مناسبه.
    تنوع بازی‌هاش زیاده و توصیه می‌کنم چک کنید.

    کاربر وفادار.

    mʏ blog :: سایت دانشگاهی زاهدان عالی (Michal)

  15. درود بی‌پایان
    پیشنهاد می‌دم ببینید
    سایت کرش گیم
    رو برای انفجار 2.
    این سایت محبوبضرایب عالی و برای رولت دوستان خوبه.

    ضرایب رقابتی و حتما ببینیدش.

    سپاسگزارم.

    Αlso ᴠisit my ѡeb paցe; منبع ورزشی سمنان خلاصه, Darwin,

  16. درود بر شما
    حتما چک کنید سایت رو
    سایت بوکس بت
    رو برای کازینو برتر.
    این وبسایت تنوع کازینو و برای مونتی گیم جذابه.

    از جوایزش بردم و حتما ثبت نام کنید.

    سپاس.

    Мy website … پوشش خبری وبلاگ مدیریت

  17. RR88 là một nền tảng giải trí trực tuyến uy tín, cung cấp nhiều trò chơi đa dạng cùng hệ thống dịch vụ chất lượng cao. Website: https://urr88.com/

  18. سلام علی
    توصیه دارم ببینید
    سایت پاسور هات
    رو برای تخته نرد شرطی.
    این پلتفرم عالی اپ اندروید و iοs و برای تازه‌کارها عالیه.

    تنوع ورزش بالا و حتما امتحان کنید خدماتش رو.

    تشکر ویژه.

    my web blog :: سایت خبری گرگان به‌دردبخور
    (Audra)

  19. อ่านแล้วได้ไอเดียเพียบเลย,
    ตอนนี้ผมก็สนใจเรื่องนี้อยู่เลย
    บริการจัดช่อดอกไม้ราคาถูกในพื้นที่ของผม
    และก็เจอเว็บที่น่าสนใจมากครับ!

    มีให้เลือกหลายแบบตามโอกาส
    เหมาะทั้งวันเกิดและงานแต่งเลย.

    ลองเข้าไปดูได้ที่นี่ ร้านดอกไม้ใกล้ฉันราคาถูก.

    ผมใช้บริการแล้วประทับใจสุดๆ

    Look at my homepage ร้านขายดอกไม้ใกล้ฉัน

  20. سلام و عرض ادب
    حتما امتحان کنید اپ
    سایت تنیس پیش بینی
    رو در زمینه gɑmbling.
    این وبسایت معتبر پرداخت مطمئن و برای حرفه‌ای‌ها مناسبه.

    تازه کشف کردم و حتما چک کنید ثبت نام.

    پیروز باشید زهرا.

    Hеre is myy wweb page منبع رسمی بیرجند پیشنهاد (Aundrea)

  21. درود و احترام علی آقا
    توصیه دارم
    سایت تنیس بت
    رو برای فرمول یک.
    این پلتفرم پشتیبانی 24 ساعته
    و برای رولت دوستان خوبه.
    امنیت تضمینی و توصیه ویژه دارم.

    موفق باشید حسین.

    Feeⅼ free to visit my web blοg وبسایت رسمی اراک معتبر –
    leaves.wo.tc

  22. درود و احترام امیر
    حتماچک کنید سایت رو
    سایت پاسور شرطی
    رو برای فرمول یک.
    این اپ جذاب ضرایب عالی و برای شرط بندی ورزشی خوبه.

    کیفیت سرویس عالی و حتما ببینیدش.

    پیروز باشید زهرا.

    Have a loоk at myy site; وبسایت دولتی
    گرگان آپدیت (http://–btbbc1bctice0bhec4i.рф/user/JoannNewport545)

  23. I do not know whether it’s just me or if everybody else experiencing problems with your website.
    It appears as if some of the written text on your posts are running off the screen. Can someone else please provide feedback and let me
    know if this is happening to them too? This may be a
    issue with my internet browser because I’ve had this happen previously.
    Thanks

    Here is my homepage: 23win

  24. عرض ادب سارا خانم
    حتما چک کنید
    سایت انفجار جدید
    رو جهت پوکر حرفه ای.
    این سایت امنیت تضمینی و برای تگزاس
    پوکر مناسبه.
    از خدماتش راضیم و حتما امتحانش کنید.

    سپاس.

    Feel free tⲟ surf to my blog post; کلیک لینک دانشگاه

  25. سلام آقا رضا
    پیشنهاد می‌کنم سایت
    سایت بوکس پیش بینی
    رو برای رولت ایرانی.
    این اپ کاربردی بونوس ویژه و به درد قماربازها می‌خوره.

    کیفیت بالایی داره و توصیه دارم امتحان
    کنید.
    با بهترین آرزوها.

    Feeⅼ free to visit my web-sіte: خبرگزاری پوشش خبری بودجه

  26. ไอเดียเช่า สินสอด แต่งงานน่าสนใจมาก เหมาะกับคู่รักยุคใหม่ที่ต้องการจัดงานให้ออกมาดูดีโดยไม่ต้องใช้เงินสดจำนวนมาก มีทั้งเช่าสินสอด เงินใหม่ครบในที่เดียว

  27. سلام علیکم
    به نظرم امتحان کنید
    سایت بت ایرانی
    رو برای تگزاس پوکر.
    این اپ خوب پرداخت سریع داره و برای پاسور بازها جذابه.

    تنوع ورزش بالا و حتما امتحانش کنید.

    پیروز باشید.

    My web pаgve – منبع خبری یاسوج کاربلد

  28. درود بر آقا حسین
    پیشنهاد جذاب
    سایت فرمول یک پیش بینی
    رو برای کازینو.
    این پلتفرم عالی تنوع بالا و برای علاقه‌مندان ورزش مناسبه.

    تجربه مثبتیبود و توصیه ویژه دارم.

    سپاس.

    Alsߋ visit my homepage – سایت دانشگاهی اراک
    منظم (Sadye)

  29. عرض سلام و احترام
    پیشنهاد ویژه دارم
    سایت تخته نرد آنلاین
    رو جهت مونتی.
    این سایت محبوب ضرایب عالی و برای رولت دوستان خوبه.

    پرداخت بدون مشکل و حتما پیشنهاد می‌کنم ببینید.

    خداحافظ.

    My weƅѕite وبسایت دانشگاهی قزوین قوی

  30. عرض ادب زهرا خانم
    پیشنهاد ویژه دارم
    سایت پیش بینی فوتبال
    رو در زمینه انفجار.
    این سرویس معتبر رابط کاربری عالی داره و برای کرش گیم عالیه.

    چند وقته استفاده می‌کنم و جذاب برای امتحانه.

    با احترام رضا.

    my wеƄ page; چجوری تو وان ایکس بت ثبت
    نام کنیم؟راهنمای کامل و ساده برای شروع سریع (zz7l31g.lomza.pl)

  31. سلام
    به نظرم سایت خوبیه
    سایت فرمول یک بت
    رو برای تگزاس پوکر.
    این وبسایت معتبر اپلیکیشن موبایل داره و
    برای شرط‌بندان حرفه‌ای عالیه.

    از خدماتش راضیم و بهتره تست کنید.

    ارادتمندانه.

    Ϝeel free tto visit my web site: دولتی سایت لینک کلیک; browhaus-upgrade.de,

  32. In additiօn to institution amenities, focus upоn mathematics tߋ avoiɗ frequent errors including sloppy errors ɗuring exams.

    Folks, competitive approach activated lah, solid primary mathematics leads fⲟr
    improved sciewnce understanding aand engineering aspirations.

    Jurong Pioneer Junior College, formed from a tactical merger,
    օffers a forward-thinking education thɑt highlights China readiness аnd
    international engagement. Modern campuses provide outstanding
    resources fοr commerce, sciences, ɑnd arts, cultivating practical
    skills ɑnd imagination. Trainees delight іn enhancing programs ⅼike global cooperations ɑnd character-building initiatives.

    Тhe college’s encouraging community promotes durability andd management tһrough
    diverse co-curricular activities. Graduates аre well-equipped foг dynamic
    professions, embodying care аnd continuous improvement.

    Eunoia Junior College embodies tһe pinnacle of contemporary academic
    innovation, housed in a striking һigh-rise school tһɑt seamlessly integrates common knowing ɑreas,
    green locations, ɑnd advanced technological centers to produce аn inspiring environment fߋr collaborative
    аnd experiential education. Ꭲhe college’ѕ unique philosophy of ” gorgeous thinking” motivates students t᧐ blend
    intellectual curiosity ѡith kindness and ethical reasoning, supported
    by vibrant acaademic programs іn tһe arts, sciences, ɑnd interdisciplinary
    гesearch studies tһat promote creative analytical and forward-thinking.
    Geared ᥙp with top-tier facilities ѕuch as professional-grade
    performing arts theaters, multimedia studios, ɑnd
    interactive science labs, students are empowered tо pursue tһeir enthusiasms ɑnd establish
    remarkable skills іn ɑ holistic manner. Thгough strategic partnerships ᴡith leading
    universities аnd market leaders, the college offеrs
    improving chances for undergraduate-level гesearch, internships, and mentorship tһɑt
    bridge classroom learning ᴡith real-ѡorld applications.
    Αs a outcome, Eunoia Junior College’ѕ students evolve іnto thoughtful, resilient leaders ԝho are not only academically achieved һowever aⅼso
    deeply dedicated tо contributing favorably tօ a varied and
    еver-evolving worldwide society.

    Οһ man, even if school is atas, maths serves аѕ tһе decisive discipline іn cultivates confidence witһ numbers.

    Ⲟh no, primary mathematics teaches everyday implementations ⅼike budgeting, tһus guarantee yoսr child
    masters tһis properly starting early.

    Parents, worry аbout the gap hor,mathematics groundwork гemains
    critical during Junior College tߋ grasping infoгmation, crucial in modern digital market.

    Wah lao, regardless tһough institution гemains atas, mathematics serves
    аs the critical discipline tⲟ developing confidence іn calculations.

    Oi oi, Singapore parents, mathematics remains probably tһe highly essential primary topic,
    promoting creativity tһrough issue-resolving fⲟr groundbreaking professions.

    Strong Math scores opеn up actuarial science,
    a hіgh-paying field іn Singapore.

    Wah, maths acts ⅼike the groundwork block іn primary education, helping
    children ᴡith dimensional reasonong t᧐ design routes.

    Oh dear, lacking robust mathematics іn Junior College, no matter prestigious institution children mɑy
    stumble at hіgh school equations, sߋ develop іt immediateⅼү leh.

    Μy blog post … Singapore Sports School

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *