Home Alone and Child Abuse

Recently, I watched Home Alone with my students.

I’ve always loved this Christmas classic. I’ve watched it every year since I can remember. It wasn’t until I was watching it with my students that I realized the real problem with this movie.

My students laughed at the treatment Kevin received.

They laughed.

They laughed at him after his mother grabbed his wrist and asked, “What is the matter with you?” after he got in a fight with his older brother, Buzz, and accidentally spilled some milk.

They laughed when his dad (or uncle maybe?) yelled, “Look what you did you little jerk.”

They laughed with his siblings and cousins joined in. “Kevin, you’re such a disease.” “Phlegm wad.” “Idiot.”

Poor Kevin even asked his mother, “Why do I always get treated like skunk?” Her reply? “There are fifteen people in this house and you’re the only one that has to make trouble.”

Kevin replies, “I’m the only one getting dumped on.”

His mother responds, “You’re the only one acting up.” She then forces him up to the third floor of their house when Kevin is clearly scared to venture up there.

As Kevin walked up the stairs, he stopped to look at his mother and say, “Everyone in this family hates me.”

At that point, she could have done the motherly thing and reassured him. She could have told him that his comment wasn’t true, that she loves him, that his father loves him. Instead, she told him that maybe he should ask Santa for a new family.

Of course, the verbal abuse isn’t the worst part. They left him home alone when they went on a trip to Paris!

The entire premise of the movie is based on child abuse – neglect.

And the whole time, my students were rolling in laughter.

That led me to wonder if movies like this have made child abuse normalized in a way. Do people think this is the proper way to treat children? Why do we use children’s misfortune as a source of laughter and comedic relief? Now, I know Macaulay Culkin (the actor that plays Kevin) was not actually being abused or neglected, that he was simply portraying a character, but I still maintain my point. Using children’s misfortune as comedic relief is absolutely asinine.

This inspired me to create this video about Hollywood’s use of child abuse in their movies. Some of the examples might shock you. Check it out and let us know how you feel about using child abuse in movies!

Survivor Stories: Leah T. (name changed for privacy)

“STEALING”

Minnesota State SVG Cut File - Snap Click Supply Co.

Photo Credit: Google Images

We are eating boiled macaroni noodles with hamburger and mushy, stewed tomatoes. It’s all mixed in together. I don’t like tomatoes, so I push them around and wedge them against the edge of my plate. I hunt for the macaroni first. And the hamburger after that. This is rather an ill thought out plan because, in this house, we must always clean our plate. So, despite my dislike of tomatoes, I will still have to eat them. And now without the macaroni or hamburger to help cover their yuck. I decide I am going to swallow large gulps of milk after I spoon in the tomatoes. Maybe that will help.

My cousin is here. He lives on a farm just up the road. He is standing in the kitchen. Over by the countertops. Next to the microwave. He is waiting there while we finish. My dad asked him if he would like to sit down and join us, but he said no because he already ate. I am not sure why he is here. Maybe to help my dad. Or to do something with my older brother.

There is a basket next to the microwave on the counter. It’s filled with “junk.” The junk is mostly stuff that comes from people’s pockets, like pennies and match books and Chapstick tubes and pieces of string. My cousin is mindlessly digging in the basket as he is standing there. I can hear the coins clinking against one another as he thumbs through them. In that moment, I don’t know why I say it. But I do. I think it’s because I am six years old and trying to be funny. I don’t mean any harm. But I say it. “Whatcha doin’ over there? Stealin’?”

Are you ready? Here it comes.

________________________________________________________________________________

What Is Physical Abuse?

Photo Credit: Google Images

A hot flash of light. At the corner of my eye. My dad yells. “LEAH*!!” Loudly. In his terrible, scary voice. In that same flash of light. It strikes. The lightning. He clobbers me. With his big hand. Across my head. Dizzy. The mean voice. “Don’t you ever say that again!” At the table. Stillness. Silence. Everyone looks down. Staring. At their plates. Paralyzed. Afraid. Me. Shaking. With terror. I stammer out the words. “I’m sorry.” He is looking at me. With those cold, hard eyes. In that crossed over place. That land of monsters and darkness and terrible screams and falling through the black sky forever and ever. A burning hot lump. Swelling. Inside my throat. Choking me. Hot tears. Clouding my eyes. The fear. The strongest. Always the strongest! Knocking my heart around. In my chest. Throwing it. With brute force. Against my ribs. Against my sternum.

My mind. Reeling. Is it over? Is it over? Please, let it be over. Is another blow coming? To knock me out of my chair? To let loose my bladder? To take away my breath? To steal all the light from the room?

Is it over?

BLACK.

I don’t remember what happens after that. It’s all fuzzy. In my mind. Like it is for many of these instances.

But I ask myself…

How did we move on in this moment? And the many moments like it? Did we choke down our food in silence and clear our plates? Did we resume conversation and pretend like nothing happened? Did we quietly disappear when our dad turned his head? How did we steal away from the fear? And the pain? Did we hide in the corner and cover our heads? Did we leave our bodies? And float into space? Did we grow wings and take flight? Did we dig a hole and burrow into the ground? Did we sneak off in the night and get lost in the darkness? Did we scream at the sky until our lungs burned red with fire? Did we walk off toward the horizon? Did we run? And run? And run? And run and run?

Yes.

We did.

*Name changed for privacy*

Don’t Call Home

“Whatever you do, do not contact home.”

Well, that’s not something I’m used to hearing as a public-school teacher.

I don’t often contact home because I never know what I’m walking into. Some parents are very respectful of me, as their child’s teacher, but some are not. Because of this, I usually avoid contacting home.

The quote above came from my principal at the time. She explained that I cannot contact home not because the student’s parents were going to harass me, but because the father had a history of abusing his son after hearing anything negative from school.


Now, let’s flash back a little bit here.

I consistently had issues with Kevin’s (named changed to protect privacy) behavior in my class. He was one of those kids who has a pure soul, but sometimes, his behavior gets out of hand. In my class, he had a hard time staying quiet, he was very antsy, and he was usually obviously uncomfortable.

I went to my principal multiple times to ask her thoughts about this situation. I was only in my second-year teaching, so I knew my management wasn’t top notch yet and I asked her if I should be managing him differently. I also asked how to make sure all students feel comfortable in my classroom, because, like already stated, he was uncomfortable in my classroom.

She explained that my management wasn’t the problem, that he has been like this for years. She also explained that because I had him seventh-hour, and he hated his home, he was probably uncomfortable because he knew he would be going home soon. She said his behavior in my class might be attributed to that as well.

At the time, I was too inexperienced to think to ask why he didn’t like to be home. I was just relieved to hear that it wasn’t my problem. I thanked her and went on my merry way.

A few weeks later, Kevin’s behavior still hadn’t improved. I had a few conversations with him during this time, and he consistently said he’d get better. At one point, I told him if it didn’t, I’d have to call home. He flipped into panic-mode and begged me to not call home.

In my infant teaching experience, Kevin’s reaction was normal. Typically, kids don’t want their parents to know they’re not behaving. His reaction was not a red flag.

Apparently, it should have been a red flag. Actually, it was a flag, waving in front of my face and I was too blind to recognize it.

In a subsequent conversation with my principal, she said, “Whatever you do, do not contact home.” I asked if the parents would ream me out for not forcing their kid to behave, which has happened in the past.

Her eyes bugged out of her head when I asked that! And she replied, “NOO. Dad will make him stack wood!”

Confused, I asked for clarification.

As it turns out, whenever Kevin’s father hears that Kevin is misbehaving, he makes him stack wood. Yes, he makes him stack wood.

Credit: Libby Penner – Unsplash.com

When Kevin gets home from school, dad sends him outside to the wood pile (they had so much wood because they heat their house with wood.). He makes Kevin take the wood off one pile and restack it on a different pile. Once he’s finished, he starts the process over. My principal said it’s not unusual for Kevin to stack the wood for a few hours and often times, he ends up missing dinner.

This is a weird form of child abuse, but it’s child abuse, nonetheless. At that time, the school had made multiple reports to the county’s child protective services (CPS), but whenever CPS went out to the house to check out the situation, dad always claimed that having his son help around the house is not child abuse. Fair enough.

I never met dad, but he apparently comes off as a really kind person so I can see how he could sweet talk CPS and convince him that Kevin was just doing some average household tasks.

It’s sickening.

Once I heard this story, I made a deal with Kevin.

I pulled him aside one day and told him what the principal had told me. It was risky, I know, but I trusted him.

I asked if that information was true. “Yes.”

I asked him how he felt when he was at home. “I hate it.”

I asked him what he felt when he was at school. “Safe.”

I told Kevin that I would never contact home as long as he did not misbehave in my classroom. We came up with a codeword. I’d walk by his desk when he wasn’t behaving, say the word, and almost immediately, he’d stop his behavior.

Kevin quickly became one of my favorite students. When I moved on to another position, he and I sat together and cried because we both knew we were losing a friendship.

Kevin and I still follow each other on social media. I see him post pictures of his truck and snowmobile. I see how happy he is with his girlfriend, another one of my past students. Overall, Kevin’s life looks really happy, but as we all know, we can’t judge someone’s life by what they post on social media.

Please remember that child abuse sometimes exists in the strangest places. For Kevin, the child abuse existed in the material his family used to heat their home in the winter.