In our Spring 2020 HiEd820: The College Student course, doctoral students had the opportunity to choose between writing a book review and participating in a course discussion. This assignment, created by Dr. Brittany Williams, was developed to help students explore academic writing forms beyond the traditional paper format and to give students an opportunity to interweave a book review with other assigned course readings. The following review was created by first-year doctoral student Kimberley Turner-Rush. Given the distance between the books’ publication and the changing realities of higher education in the current political landscape, this text remains relevant to all who seek to serve and support students on campus. If you’re looking for a quarantine read that can shed light on educational precarity and access issues, this book should be on your list.

— Brittany M. Williams, Ph.D.

LOWER ED: The Troubling Rise of For-Profit Colleges in the New Economy (Review)

Cottom, T.M. (2017). Lower Ed. The Troubling Rise of For-Profit Colleges in the New Economy. New York, NY. The New Press.

Many have viewed education as a way to change the trajectory of an entire family for generations to come (Song, 2016). Cottom’s (2017) book, Lower Ed: The Troubling Rise of For-Profit Colleges in the New Economy, provides readers insight on how students’ socioeconomic status plays a role in higher education. Cottom not only addresses attainment, but also the types of educational opportunities that are available to students as well as how the systems in place can both discourage their participation and take advantage of their desire for participation.

Championed as the great equalizer, higher education has been dangled like a carrot to lower- and lower-middle-class people as a way to climb the socioeconomic ladder to a better life.

Photo by Dr. Tressie McMillan Cottom via Wikimedia Commons

Currently an Associate Professor in the Department of Sociology at Virginia Commonwealth University, Cottom hails from a professional background of working at both for-profit and not-for-profit institutions of higher education. Her experience provides insight into practices of enrolling students in programs that, more often than not, do not meet the expectations outlined and can often leave students in financial distress. Cottom’s disdain for these practices is evident as she proclaims, “the idea that higher education is a moral good is allowable only insofar as higher education serves market interests.” 

When we remove the notion that, for many, obtaining higher education is more about job attainment and less about the social good, we are forced to look in the mirror and ask whether or not the work of higher education institutions as we currently conceive it functions for all students who are enrolling with the hope of a brighter future. Cottom provides the reader with insight or themes impacting how we, as practitioners, interact with students as well as how we should be working with populations of students who need our services most.

When reading Lower Ed, themes that practitioners should consider emerge regarding processes for recruiting and enrolling students, labor market drivers for programming, and organizational structures to support students determined to complete a college education. These takeaways should continue to be at the forefront of discussions of higher education practitioners and shape how we serve our students. It is our responsibility to rethink both our purpose(s) as higher education practitioners and our understanding of what students want (and need) from our institutions.

Recruitment and Enrollment Practices

Cottom remarkably illustrates how the “flexible solutions” offered by the for-profit schools continue to exacerbate social inequities and foster discrimination.

Students enrolling in these programs are less likely to have attended good K-12 schools that offer college prep courses. They are more likely to face food and housing insecurities (AAC&U News, 2019) and less likely to have access to standardized test prep. By seeking education at a for-profit institution, they are more likely to take on higher debt to cover the higher costs.

The not-for-profit sector must find ways to allow flexible enrollment schedules, online courses, and online program completion as just a few of the benefits students can expect. Additionally, many for-profit institutions do not require developmental courses, so students start immediately on their chosen academic path. In addition to finding ways to better accommodate the for-profit demographic, we must do so in a way that reduces equity gaps as these students are more likely to fall into a group that Anthony Jack refers to as the doubly disadvantaged (2015).  Cottom indicates that students often feel pressured into signing enrollment agreements and that they do not fully understand the burden of this debt. 

Doubly Disadvantaged

Jack’s (2015) work compares the experience of students of color who enter college from local, public high schools (doubly disadvantaged) and those students of color who graduate from preparatory or boarding schools (privileged poor). These distinctions are essential in understanding the needs of the students we serve. The doubly disadvantaged have had little access to the resources that make college transition smooth and college completion attainable. These students are unaware that professors expect students to reach out if they need help and expect students to seek assistance when obstacles arise. Using the close relationships with our K-12 partners, not-for-profit institutions of higher education are positioned to have discussions on how to close these gaps. If we fail to do so, we are complacent and are further enabling a system that, as Cottom indicates, continues to exacerbate social inequities and fosters discrimination.

Labor Market Drivers

Students enrolled in for-profit institutions tend to be women, people of color, and single parents who are of lower socioeconomic status than their traditional college peers (Cottom, 2017). For many of these individuals, a college education provides preparation for a job, knowledge needed for a better job, or credentials required to pursue a coveted position and be competitive in the job market.

istockphoto.com

While access barriers are a large driver to for-profit undergraduate programs, why do for-profit graduate degrees continue to flourish? Cottom offers one example that focuses on a group of black women enrolled in online PhD programs offered mainly through the University of Phoenix, Capella University, and Walden University. These women, known as Sisters Working to Achieve Greatness (SWAG), are obtaining what Cottom refers to as up-market degrees at a much higher cost without the off-setting opportunities such as teaching assistantships or institutional aid. Up-market degrees are “credential sequences that start at the lower level, with higher degrees stacked on top as demand increases” (Cottom, 2017). The women of SWAG are spending $92,000 to $180,000 for degrees (up to and including the doctorate) through student loans. While these women see the cost as a good investment, others Cottom follows view education as a means to add letters behind their name for the perceived prestige those letters provide.

 

Organizational Structure and Student Support

One way that community colleges strive to support students is through innovation and wrap-around services such as childcare resources, tutoring, transportation, etc. (Dembicki, 2019).

Cottom counters with the fact that the understaffing of community colleges in service areas, overcrowding, and demands of remedial or developmental courses put strains on these institutions and leave students to overcome these obstacles on their own. Obstacles that students are less likely to face in the for-profit sector.

It is evident that the current not-for-profit systems are not meeting students’ needs in overcoming these obstacles. Much of this relates to the difference in funding structures between not-for-profit and for-profit institutions. To improve these systems and be better positioned to meet the needs of students, community colleges (and four-year institutions) will need a better funding model that offers incentives for the necessary changes to be made. Until then, Cottom offers focus areas (themes) that practitioners can use when developing or updating services and programs that serve the students most in need of our support. Perhaps we should all heed her advice.

References

AAC&U News. (2019). Majority of College Students Experience Food Insecurity, Housing Insecurity, or Homelessness.

Cottom, T. M. (2017). Lower Ed; The Troubling Rise of For-Profit Colleges in the New Economy. The New Press.

Dembricki, M. (2019). Wraparound services and student success. Community College Daily. Retrieved http://www.ccdaily.com/2019/05/wraparound-services-student-success/.

Jack, A. (2015).  “What the Privileged Poor Can Teach Us.” The New York Times.

Jack, A. (2019, June 13). On Diversity: Access Ain’t Inclusion. TEDxCambridge. https://youtu.be/j7w2Gv7ueOc.

Jack, A. (2019, March 6). The Privileged Poor. YouTube. https://youtu.be/ZXKKmPCZPDc

Song, X. (2016). Diverging Mobility Trajectories: Grandparent Effects on Educational Attainment in One- and Two-Parent Families. Demography. 53(6). 1905-1932.

U.S. Department of Education. College Affordability and Completion: Ensuring a Pathway to Opportunity. https://www.ed.gov/college.

 

About the Author:

Kim Turner-Rush is an instructor of business at Saint Paul College. She lives in downtown Saint Paul, a transplant from Cincinnati, OH. She holds a M.A. in Higher Education Administration and an MBA from Morehead State University. Currently, Kim is enrolled in the Higher Education Administration doctoral program at Saint Cloud State University.

3,854 thoughts on “What is “Lower Ed” and Are We Continuing to Push it On Students?

  1. 789bet không ngừng đổi mới nhằm cung cấp nhiều tính năng hữu ích và đáp ứng nhu cầu giải trí của khách hàng.

  2. I must thank you for the efforts you have put in penning this
    site. I am hoping to see the same high-grade
    blog posts by you in the future as well. In truth, your creative writing abilities has inspired me to
    get my own, personal blog now 😉

    Also visit my page :: https://vu8899.com/e-sports-vu88/

  3. Thanks for the auspicious writeup. It if truth be told used to be a
    leisure account it. Glance complex to far added agreeable from you!
    By the way, how can we keep in touch?

    Also visit my homepage: xổ số mv66

  4. Nice to be visiting your blog once more, it has been months for me. Well this article that ive been waited for therefore long. i want this article to finish my assignment within the faculty, and it has same topic together with your article. Thanks, nice share. Iwin68

  5. Aiyo, choose thoughtfully leh, leading institutions focus оn morals аnd structure,
    molding leaders fоr professional οr public sector
    wins.

    Guardians, competitive а bіt lah, tоp schools hаve skilled tutors, assuring һigh PSLE scores for choice secondary schools.

    Ιn addition beүond school resources, focus ԝith arithmetic
    f᧐r prevent frequent mistakes including careless errors ɑt tests.

    Hey hey, steady pom рi pi, math remains among fгom the top subjects in primary
    school, laying base fоr A-Level calculus.

    Aiyo, minus strong mathematics аt primary school, regardless prestigious establishment youngsters сould struggle wіtһ next-level algebra,
    so develop it immeԀiately leh.

    Guardians, competitive mode оn lah, solid primary math guides іn Ƅetter STEM comprehension and construction dreams.

    Ɗ mess around lah, combine a good primary school alongside mathematics excellence іn oгⅾеr tо assure elevated PSLE
    scores рlus smooth shifts.
    Parents, dread tһe disparity hor, arithmetic groundwork proves vital іn primary school іn grasping figures,
    crucial fοr modern tech-driven ѕystem.

    St. Anthony’s Canossian Primary School οffers a values-centered learning experience.

    Ꮃith caring staff, it influences women tߋ excel holistically.

    CHIJ Oᥙr Lady of the Nativity оffers ɑ supportive environment fоr ladies’ growth.

    Ԝith strong programs in arts and academics, іt promotes imagination.
    Parents аppreciate іts dedication to ⲟverall development.

    Feel free tо surf to mу web-site Raffles Girls’ School

  6. F8BET Cân bằng giữa May Mắn và Chiến Thuật. Tỷ lệ thưởng công bằng, thanh toán sòng phẳng. Chơi có trách nhiệm, thắng có đẳng cấp.

  7. Howdy! This is my 1st comment here so I just wanted to give a quick shout out and say I genuinely enjoy
    reading your posts. Can you recommend any other blogs/websites/forums
    that cover the same topics? Thanks a ton!

    Also visit my blog post; Nổ hũ HM88

  8. I have to thank you for the efforts you have put in penning this website.
    I really hope to see the same high-grade content by you in the future as well.
    In fact, your creative writing abilities has encouraged me to
    get my own website now 😉

    Take a look at my web-site – Thuốc lắc

  9. Hello There. I found your blog using msn. This is an extremely
    well written article. I will be sure to bookmark it and return to read more of your useful info.
    Thanks for the post. I will definitely comeback.

    Also visit my web blog … website

  10. Interesting article! Sports fans will love this news on global events.
    I rely on sites like this for updates on athletics.
    Everyone should explore live cricket
    for fresh updates.

  11. Good day I am so delighted I found your webpage, I really found you
    by error, while I was browsing on Google for something else, Nonetheless I am here now and would just
    like to say kudos for a incredible post and a all round thrilling blog (I also love the theme/design),
    I don’t have time to read it all at the minute but I have bookmarked it
    and also added in your RSS feeds, so when I have
    time I will be back to read more, Please do keep up the fantastic work.

    my web page: game bài mv66

  12. I have read so many posts concerning the blogger lovers
    except this article is truly a pleasant post, keep it up.

    Feel free to surf to my web page – Xổ số WIN678

  13. Hello there, just became alert to your blog through Google, and found that it’s truly informative.
    I’m going to watch out for brussels. I’ll be grateful if you continue this
    in future. Lots of people will be benefited from your writing.
    Cheers!

    Feel free to surf to my webpage: phim sex hiếp dâm học sinh

  14. I do not know whether it’s just me or if perhaps everybody
    else experiencing issues with your blog. It appears as if
    some of the text in your posts are running off the screen. Can somebody else please comment and let me know if this is happening to them too?
    This might be a problem with my web browser because I’ve had this happen previously.
    Appreciate it

    my web blog url

  15. V9bet tự hào là điểm đến giải trí trực tuyến hàng đầu tại châu Á, mang đến hàng loạt tựa game đỉnh cao từ cược thể thao, slot game đến bắn cá. Giao diện hiện đại, tỷ lệ cược hấp dẫn và nền tảng ổn định giúp người chơi tận hưởng trải nghiệm mượt mà suốt 24/7. Nền tảng bảo mật cao cấp cùng chính sách hỗ trợ khách hàng tận tâm luôn đặt trải nghiệm người dùng lên hàng đầu. Website: https://v9bet266.com/

  16. Hi there to every , as I am genuinely eager of reading this blog’s post to be
    updated daily. It contains pleasant information.

    my web page; url

  17. x88 mang đến cho người chơi một không gian cá cược trực tuyến an toàn, minh bạch – đảm bảo đạt chuẩn các tiêu chí về số lượng trò chơi và chất lượng dịch vụ. Bên cạnh đó, nhà cái còn được đánh giá cao nhờ có tiềm lực tài chính vững mạnh, đảm bảo luôn có đa dạng khuyến mãi khủng cùng tốc độ trả thưởng nhanh chóng. Truy cập ngay!

  18. Mums аnd Dads, kiasu style activated lah, strong primary math guides
    tо superior science understanding аs ԝell as engineering aspirations.

    Wow, math is tһe base stone for primary learning, helping kids ѡith
    geometric thinking f᧐r design routes.

    Dunman Ꮋigh School Junior College masters multilingual education, blending Eastern аnd
    Western perspectives tⲟ cultivate culturally astute and ingenious thinkers.
    Τһe incorporated program ⲟffers smooth development ᴡith enriched curricula іn STEM аnd liberal
    arts, suppoted by advanced facilities ⅼike rеsearch labs.
    Students prosper іn an unified environment tһat emphasizes creativity, management, аnd community involvement tһrough diverse activities.
    Worldwide immersion programs boost cross-cultural understanding аnd prepare students fߋr worldwide
    success. Graduates regularly achieve t᧐p results,
    reflecting the school’ѕ dedication to scholastic rigor and individual excellence.

    Hwa Chong Institution Junior College іѕ celebrated fⲟr іts
    seamless integrated program tһat masterfully
    combines extensive scholastic difficulties ᴡith extensive character advancement, cultivating ɑ brand-new generation of
    international scholars аnd ethical leaders ᴡho are equipped tⲟ tackle intricate international concerns.
    Ꭲhe institution boasts ԝorld-class facilities, including
    innovative proving ground, multilingual libraries, ɑnd
    innovation incubators, ᴡһere highly qualified professors guide students tоwards excellence іn fields
    lіke clinical research, entrepreneurial ventures, аnd
    cultural studies. Trainees acquire indispensable expoeriences tһrough
    substantial worldwide exchange programs,
    global competitions іn mathematics аnd sciences, and collective tasks
    that expand tһeir horizons and improve tһeir analytical ɑnd interpersonal skills.
    Вy stressing innovation tһrough efforts lіke student-led start-ᥙps and innovation workshops, ɑlоng with service-oriented activities tһat promote social responsibility,
    the coloege constructs resilience, adaptability, ɑnd a strong morazl foundation in іtѕ learners.

    Τhe vast alumni network οf Hwa Chong Institution Junior College
    ⲟpens pathways tⲟ elite universities аnd prominent professions ɑcross tһe
    woгld, highlighting the school’s enduring
    tradition օf cultivating intellectual expertise аnd principled management.

    Folks, competitive style activated lah, strong primary maths leads іn superior scientific understanding ɑnd engineering aspirations.

    Oi oi, Singapore folks, mathematics proves ⅼikely the highly essential primary topic, fostering imagination іn challenge-tackling іn groundbreaking
    careers.

    Aiyo, withоut solid maths during Junior College, гegardless prestigious school
    kids mіght struggle with next-level calculations, theгefore develop tһat
    noѡ leh.

    A-level distinctions іn core subjects lіke Math ѕet you apart from the crowd.

    Eh eh,composed pom ⲣi pi, mathematics proves one of tһe leading topics in Junior College, building
    foundation іn A-Level һigher calculations.

    Βesides t᧐ school facilities, focus ᥙpon maths in order tօ
    avoiⅾ common pitfalls like inattentive blunders іn assessments.

    Feel free to surf tо my blog post … Hwa Chong JC

  19. We’re a group of volunteers and opening a new scheme in our
    community. Your web site offered us with
    valuable info to work on. You have done a formidable job and our entire community will
    be grateful to you.

    Also visit my webpage; website mua bán ma túy

  20. Oi oi, Singapore moms аnd dads, mathematics гemains probabⅼy
    the mоst essential primary discipline, encouraging imagination іn issue-resolving
    for groundbreaking professions.
    Ꭰo not take lightly lah, combine ɑ gooⅾ Junior College alongside mathematics
    proficiency іn оrder to ensure elevated А Levels marks plus effortless transitions.

    Ѕt. Joseph’s Institution Junior Collsge embodies Lasallian traditions, stressing faith, service, аnd intellectual pursuit.
    Integrated programs provide smooth progression ᴡith concentrate on bilingualism and innovation. Facilities ⅼike performing arts centers boost
    creative expression. International immersions ɑnd rеsearch chances
    expand рoint of views. Graduates аre thoughtful achievers, excelling іn universities аnd professions.

    Ѕt. Joseph’s Institution Junior College maintains valued
    Lasallian customs оf faith, service, ɑnd intellectual curiosity, producing ɑn empowering environment wherе trainees pursue knowledge ѡith enthusiasm аnd commit tһemselves to uplifting otһers
    tһrough caring actions. Thе integrated program mɑkes sure a fluid
    development fгom secondary to pre-university levels, ѡith а concentrate on bilingual efficiency аnd ingenious curricula
    supported ƅy centers ⅼike advanced performing arts centers ɑnd science rеsearch labs that influence
    imaginative ɑnd analytical excellence. International immersion experiences,
    consisting оf global service journeys and cultural exchange programs, widen students’ horizons, improve
    linguistic skills, аnd foster a deep appreciation foг diverse worldviews.
    Opportunities for sophisticated гesearch study,
    management functions іn trainee organizations, ɑnd mentorship from accomplished professors build ѕelf-confidence,
    critical thinking, аnd a commitment tо long-lasting knowing.
    Graduates are understood for their compassion and hіgh achievements, protecting
    locations іn prominent universities and mastering careers tһat line up ԝith the college’s values ᧐f service аnd intellectual rigor.

    Parents, fearful of losing style οn lah, robust primary math
    results t᧐ superior scientific understanding and tech
    goals.

    Aiyo, mіnus solid mathematics Ԁuring Junior College, no matter prestigious institution children mіght falter аt secondary algebra, thᥙs build tһіs pгomptly leh.

    Parents, competitive style engaged lah, solid primary mathematics leads іn better STEM understanding рlus construction dreams.

    Math trains precision, reducing errors іn future professional roles.

    Oh no, primary mathematics educates everyday implementations including budgeting, ѕо
    ensure your kid masters tһis right beginning young age.

    my web-site :: add math tuition punggol

  21. Tốc độ truy cập của GK88 được cải thiện liên tục để đảm bảo trải nghiệm mượt mà.

  22. Hey are using WordPress for your site platform? I’m new to the blog world but I’m
    trying to get started and set up my own. Do you need any coding knowledge to make your own blog?
    Any help would be really appreciated!

    Take a look at my webpage :: gilabet888

  23. Don’tplay play lah, elite schools educate financial skills ѕoon, positioning uⲣ for wealth
    handling professions.

    Eh eh, tоp establishments incorporate meditation, promoting concentration fߋr intense career positions.

    Aiyo, mіnus strong math ɑt primary school, no matter tоp institution youngsters may falter іn next-level algebra, ѕߋ cultivate it promptly leh.

    Alas, lacking solid arithmetic ⅾuring primary school, еven top establishment
    kids could falter ԝith secondary calculations, ѕo cultivate іt promptly leh.

    Goodness, еven though institution iѕ atas, arithmetic is the
    critical discipline tο developing poise ѡith numbers.

    Listen ᥙp,steady pom pі pi, aithmetic is one in thе top disciplines аt primary
    school, building groundwork tο A-Level calculus.

    Folks, kiasu style ߋn lah, solid primary arithmetic guides іn better scientific understanding
    and engineering aspirations.

    CHIJ Primary (Toa Payoh) fosters ɑ lively knowing neighborhood rooted
    іn Catholic traditions.
    Τhe school’s focus on holistic development prepares students fߋr long-lasting success.

    Compassvale Primary School ᧐ffers cutting edge facilities
    for knowing.
    The school promotes STEM ɑnd arts fοr holistic growth.

    Moms and dads apprteciate itѕ forward-thinking curriculum.

    Feel free tο visit mү web ρage … NUS Нigh School Of Mathematics
    And Science (R12Imob.Store)

  24. 888new cc đang dần khẳng định vị thế của mình trong lĩnh vực giải trí trực tuyến với sự kết hợp hài hòa giữa công nghệ hiện đại, dịch vụ tiện ích. Người chơi được trải nghiệm những trò chơi hấp dẫn và luôn yên tâm về tính an toàn, minh bạch trong mọi giao dịch. Bài viết này dành cho những ai đang tìm kiếm một sân chơi uy tín, có thể hiểu rõ hơn về nhà cái nhằm mang lại sự an tâm và trải nghiệm giải trí trọn vẹn.

  25. 23win06 là nhà cái cá cược trực tuyến uy tín hàng đầu châu Á, thu hút hàng nghìn bet thủ Việt Nam nhờ sự an toàn – đẳng cấp – minh bạch trong từng trải nghiệm. Nền tảng cung cấp hệ sinh thái giải trí toàn diện gồm cá cược thể thao, nổ hũ, lô đề online cùng vô số khuyến mãi độc quyền. 

  26. https://69vnn.ninja/ – Nhà cái trực tuyến uy tín hàng đầu châu Á, cung cấp đầy đủ các sản phẩm cá cược hấp dẫn như thể thao, game bài và slot. Với giao diện thân thiện, nạp rút nhanh chóng và chính sách bảo mật cao, 69VN mang đến trải nghiệm giải trí an toàn, minh bạch và công bằng cho tất cả người tham gia.

  27. Impressive article! Sports fans will love this coverage on global events.
    I always follow sites like this for updates on cricket. Everyone should visit sport news hindi for trusted updates.

  28. I think the admin of this web page is genuinely working hard in support
    of his web site, for the reason that here every information is quality based material.

    My page bet88

  29. Aw, this was an incredibly nice post. Taking the time and actual effort to make a
    really good article… but what can I say… I procrastinate a lot and never seem to get anything
    done.

    my blog post url

  30. BL555 – nhà cái cá cược hàng đầu Việt Nam mang đến không gian giải trí hiện đại, an toàn và chuyên nghiệp. Người chơi có thể tham gia đa dạng trò chơi từ thể thao, đá gà đến bắn cá đổi thưởng. Hệ thống nạp rút siêu tốc và nhiều ưu đãi hấp dẫn đang chờ bạn!

  31. 99 OK chú trọng vào trải nghiệm người dùng, mang lại sự mượt mà và ổn định trong suốt quá trình sử dụng.

    1. https://ok365ok.net/ – Nhà cái trực tuyến uy tín hàng đầu châu Á, nổi bật với giao diện hiện đại, tốc độ xử lý nhanh và tỷ lệ cược hấp dẫn. Ok365 cung cấp đa dạng sản phẩm như cá cược thể thao, bắn cá, game bài và slot đổi thưởng, mang đến trải nghiệm giải trí an toàn, minh bạch và chuyên nghiệp cho mọi người chơi.

  32. Trải nghiệm ngay BL555 nhà cái chuẩn quốc tế với kho game khổng lồ: thể thao, casiino, slot, bắn cá… Hệ thống bảo mật tiên tiến, nạp rút 24/7, tỷ lệ thắng cao nhất thị trường. Thắng lớn mỗi ngày cùng BL555!

  33. 68wim mang đến không gian cá cược trực tuyến đẳng cấp, nơi người chơi được tận hưởng hàng loạt kèo cược thể thao sôi động cùng tỷ lệ trả thưởng cực hấp dẫn. Với nhiều chương trình khuyến mãi lớn, 68WIM là điểm đến lý tưởng cho những ai muốn thử vận may, thể hiện chiến thuật và săn thưởng mỗi ngày. Tham gia ngay để hòa mình vào không khí cá cược đầy kịch tính và cơ hội thắng lớn đang chờ đón bạn.

Leave a Reply to https://ok365ok.net/ Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *