Reality vs Myths

Reality of an ESL Teacher

It has been 49 days since I saw my students and coworkers. I chose to dedicate my life to helping my students achieve and develop into young adults. I never predicted that the last trimester of my second year of teaching would be online. 

As I spend my days waiting for my students to send a message or join Google Meet, I also reminisce about how long I have known some of these students. I am a second year teacher, but I have been working at the same school for four years. I was a field experience student, teacher candidate, long-call substitute, summer school teacher, and finally full time. With four years at the same school, I have known most of my eighth graders since they were sixth graders. There is one student in particular that stands out from that group because he says, “We go way back.”  He’s right. We do go way back. We met during my first field experience placement when he was in fourth grade. I have had the privilege of watching this student grow up, learn another language, and develop into the jokester we always knew he was. I am saddened to think I will not hear him brag about how long he has known me and I am disappointed they are all missing out on the Spring Fling and other end of the year celebrations.

I miss instructing my students and being able to see and hear their progress. I miss our silly conversations about their lives and how they are too invested in my wedding plans. Even when this pandemic ends, life will never be the same. They have missed out on major moments in their childhoods and as a teacher, I have missed out on helping them get there. There are many things I wish I could have known before becoming a teacher. There are many things I still have to learn myself, but the least I can do for you today is share what I do know. It is time for us to talk about what it is really like to be a teacher of ESL.  Today my goal is to debunk some of the myths that go along with teaching ESL and give you more of an insight to the reality of this profession.

Five Myths About Teaching ESL

ESL teachers need to speak the language(s) of their students.

I cannot count how many times I have been asked if I was fluent in the languages my students speak. If I was, I would be fluent in English, Somali, Arabic, Spanish, and Creole. Don’t get me wrong. Teaching my diverse group would be much easier with a stronger background with their languages. To bridge the gap between languages, I have put an emphasis on learning phrases and keywords in each language, as well as becoming familiar with their cultural traditions. This simple gesture goes a long way in building strong, respectful relationships with students.

Your job will be fulfilling EVERYDAY.

As much as we want to have amazing days everyday, it is impossible. We can strive for great days, great lessons, and great attitudes; and manage to survive a chaotic day, failed lesson, or bad attitude. During my teacher candidacy, my cooperating teacher would say, “Let’s chalk it up as a fail and do better tomorrow.” She knew not every lesson or class would go right, which made teaching that much better. We cannot put high expectations on every aspect of our teaching. We need to leave room for adjustments and be willing to start from the beginning when necessary.

Teaching only happens in the classroom.

Distance learning, e-learning, and traditional learning are all forms of teaching we have become more familiar with during this time. Most people believe teaching only happens in the classroom and students will not learn outside of their regular learning environment. Some of my students have checked out for the year because they do not want to learn from a distance. Others are thriving because they are able to get the help they need from instructional videos and tutorials. It is possible for learning to happen outside of the physical classroom, but it takes time to develop online classroom routines, expectations, and management procedures.

Many of my students began learning English from listening to American music, binge watching shows on Netflix with English subtitles, and making friends who are native speakers or multilingual speakers who share the same language. I really encourage my students to read novels that also have movies. This way they can have multiple opportunities to read and hear the words. Through these outside learning opportunities, they are able to interact with the language and acquire basic skills to continue working on when they get back to the classroom.

Every teacher has their own classroom.  

Wrong. As an ESL teacher, I am also required to co-teach for a portion of my day. When I first began teaching, I had three co-teachers and did not teach a class alone. It was a struggle to find a balance as a new teacher, but it only got worse when I had to ask one of the three co-teachers if I could put my desk (that I had to request from the custodial staff to find) in her room. Almost finished with my second year and I still had to find a new home for my desk back in August. I also co-teach 4/5 classes and had to find an empty classroom to house my advisory and EL Developing Reading classes. Basically, do not assume you will get your own room with a desk and a chair right away. Schools tend to have more teachers than they do classrooms, so if you plan to teach ESL prepare yourself for this possibility.

Anyone can teach English if they speak it.

The reality of the situation is that a lot of people think they could teach something and I admit they are not completely wrong. They might be able to teach a skill like throwing a ball, basic math, or the ABC’s, but can they manage behaviors, while differentiating a lesson for 35 students? Probably not. Teaching is not for everyone, as I am sure you know. Not everyone could handle the stress and excitement of being a teacher. 

As an ESL teacher, I have experienced a lot of people saying it must be easy since I am a native speaker. Trust me, it is not easy at all. Teaching students who have various English proficiency levels and learning styles has many challenges. Currently I work with students considered level 3, meaning they are not beginners but more so intermediate. Typically, conversational speech happens quickly for many learners and reading and writing are the most difficult. Teaching someone how to read and write takes a lot of time and lots of phonics practice. Repetition is key when learning a language. Students need multiple interactions with a word before they are able to read, write, say, and hear it. This only happens when a teacher provides those opportunities throughout a lesson. 

For example, to learn academic vocabulary I will read a story from the textbook to my class that contains the words they are learning. Then I will have them read with a partner or they will take turns reading aloud to the class. They are required to participate in discussions about the text and I provide them with sentence frames to encourage an academic discussion. They will also complete various writing activities to practice using the vocabulary words. These are not things every teacher is trained to provide to their students. But an ESL teacher is trained and will be able to scaffold a lesson to fit the needs of all of their diverse learners (with practice, of course).

Even though teaching ESL is not at all what I expected, I have been able to learn so much through my many experiences in the classroom. Teaching has its ups and downs like any profession, but I believe it is one of the most rewarding. We get to experience our students learning from mistakes, achieving, and establishing their personalities. If debunking one myth at a time is what it takes to encourage more people to be educators, then that is what I will do.

To keep updated follow us on Instagram and Twitter.

The New Normal: ESL Tutoring Online

When we left for Spring Break, it seemed like business as usual and we expected to return to school a week later picking up where we left off. As the writing center coordinator at St. Cloud Technical Community College (SCTCC), I took a few days off to rest, relax, and recharge for the remainder of the semester. When I returned to work, Spring Break had been extended for two weeks and instructors were informed they would deliver courses online for the remainder of the semester. For those of us working at SCTCC’s tutoring center the Center for Academic Success (CAS), it meant finding ways to continue to offer our services to students, but from a distance.

With these changes came new guidelines for students coming to the CAS for help, and also my staff as well. Not only are my tutors dealing with the challenge of taking all of their classes online, but now must learn a new manner for tutoring. No more will they have the opportunity for physical contact with a student’s paper, or have the chance to sit across from the student having a conversation on assignment expectations.

Their interactions will be with computer screens through Zoom chats or responding to student drafts by typing comments. As a tutor who overall believes in minimalist tutoring, I fear that tutors may begin acting as editors rather than tutors. Instead of giving explanations for why a change should be made, they may make the change for the student returning a paper improved from a writing perspective. While the student may appreciate this, the encounter has hurt the tutor’s standing with the student and has stultified the student’s writing journey. While I am concerned with the possibility of this happening to any of the students, it raises particular concern for our ELL students. If they become reliant upon tutors making corrections to papers, these students will be placed in a precarious position moving forward both at SCTCC and at other academic institutions.

My Greatest Concern
A reason for my concern is finding the balance between instructor/student expectations and what it means to be a good tutor. Often ELL students come in with assignment sheets that read “for every grammatical or spelling error, one point will be deducted from this paper” or similar expectations. As a result, many students want to focus on sentence level issues like spelling or subject/verb agreement. An experienced tutor will notice these errors in the paper, but usually there will be bigger issues such as organization or lack of a coherent thesis statement (or the complete lack thereof). While these problems are not exclusive to ELL students, they occur with more frequency. Balancing the student’s desire for grammar and spelling help against higher order concerns like assignment expectations and learning about the process of writing is just one of the many challenges a tutor faces.

A Resource to Help
In an effort to prevent negative practices from occurring, I revisited by Ben Rafoth’s article titled “Responding Online.” The article is chapter ten in the book ESL Writers: A Guide for Writing Center Tutors 2nd Edition edited by Rafoth and his colleague Shanti Bruce. The entire book is a great resource and has been a constant companion throughout my tutoring and coordinating journey. If you work with ELL students on any subject, this book is fantastic resource filled with information on working with ELL students, and I highly recommend it.

In the tenth chapter, Rafoth discusses how he helped his writing tutors provide constructive feedback to ELL students who had emailed papers to the writing center. Rafoth gave many useful tips, but in particular offers four guidelines for his student tutors to follow when responding to online submissions.

  1. Less is more when it comes to writing comments
  2. Focus and consistency is paramount
  3. Direct but polite feedback is regarded as most helpful
  4. How tutors read a writer’s paper affects the responses

Each of these tips builds upon the previous one making it a practical progression for the ESL tutor to follow when responding to student drafts. While Rafoth is primarily concerned with his tutors responding to ELL students (as am I), his suggestions are ones that would be applicable for any tutor responding to online papers.

Less is more when it comes to writing comments
The first issue Rafoth delves into is giving too much feedback. Often in an effort to be thorough, student tutors comment on every problem in a paper. They do not necessarily ‘edit’ the paper, but they comment on every missed comma, additional space, and misspelled word along with higher order concerns as well. While thoroughness is admirable, it creates situations where the student is overwhelmed by the number of comments and suggested corrections. If a tutor has more comments than the student has text, the tutor has made too many comments.

Rafoth admits that the conscientious nature of the comments comes from the right place, but it lacks the direction that some ELL students require. If students see too many comments, they may think starting over would be easier. I have seen this tendency with some of my own student tutors and feel the need to fight this habit in myself occasionally.

Focus and consistency is paramount
The second element Rafoth emphasizes is the need for focused and consistent feedback. I have noticed that at times tutors will not have an overall goal with the comments they write. Sometimes it concerns punctuation and other times content. Rafoth mentions it is best to stay on one track when working with an ELL student. The tutor should focus on one issue and giving advice and pointers in regard to that issue. If the tutor starts to discuss other issues in addition to the primary one, it may cause confusion in the student who might believe that the spacing issues in the fourth and sixth paragraphs are linked to the issues with the thesis statement in the first paragraph. Thus maintaining a focus throughout the paper is not only useful for the student, but also for the tutor.

Direct but polite feedback is regarded as most helpful
Rafoth’s third suggestion is the one I struggle with the most. He mentions direct, yet polite feedback is the most useful and helps to build the confidence the student has in the tutor. Frequently, when offering feedback, I write a sentence like: “Perhaps you might want to consider thinking about it this way,” or “It might be beneficial for you to restate your thesis at some point in your conclusion.” When I reread my comments, I make them more positive and declarative statements as opposed to suggestive and wishy-washy comments.

Statements like the ones above are not useful as the student may think the tutor is unsure of their advice. Stronger statements like: “modify your thesis to discuss what the rest of your paper is about” or “you should restate your thesis in your conclusion.” This tendency to offer suggestive comments no doubt comes from a history of wanting the student to maintain ownership over his or her paper. If I come across too strongly with my comments, the paper may become more about what I envision for the paper as opposed to what the student wishes to write. This was useful to reread during this time of online tutoring and was something I passed on to all of my student tutors.

How tutors read a writer’s paper affects the responses
The final point Rafoth makes refers to how a tutor reads a paper and how the feedback will be affected. Tutors need to come into the tutoring session with realistic expectations of what the writer is capable of and where they are academically. Many tutors hope to get their students to the point of being able to produce a solid academic paper at the end of a tutoring session. This is not always possible. In fact, what it does is create unrealistic expectations for some ELL writers early in their academic careers. It is better to meet the student where they are in the writing process, and understand that there will be some errors you may not fix. There might be some issues that are not addressed until the next assignment, but the important thing is to have realistic expectations. An ELL student, taking their first college class, will most likely not produce the same quality paper as a NES (Native English Speaker). Thus, we should not read their papers with those expectations in mind.

Closing Thoughts
Rafoth’s book was a great help to me when I was learning the ins-and-outs of working with ELL students and it has helped me to learn different methods for working with these students. Revisiting his book at this time helped me provide insights to the student tutors I am working with and will help us to better serve the students that will be making use of our online tutoring services for the remainder of the semester.

Follow us on Twitter and Instagram to receive updates and our blog post, tips for learning and teaching English, and more adventures.